I am entirely used to being sent books to review, and sometimes albums too. But this week I received an unusual package through the post: a clergy shirt to review!
Butler and Butler are two brothers, one of whom is ordained. They couldn't believe it when they discovered it was impossible to buy a clergy shirt that was guaranteed fair trade, so they went into business together to do something about it. I was impressed by their principles when I read about their venture, but (to be completely honest) I was initially sceptical. You may think I'm shallow, but I really like to look smart when I go to work, and most clergy gear makes you look like a rag bag. What hope would there be if it was fair trade as well?
Well. I stand corrected. This shirt is not only easy on the conscience, it is also undoubtedly the nicest clergy shirt I've ever worn. The fabric is 100% cotton, very soft and fine, not crispy or shiny like many clergy shirts, and the styling is - yes!! - quite simply a classic cut woman's business shirt. Not a semi-adapted baggy blokey shirt, nor a confection of dated frills or puffy sleeves or flowers. Just a really smart, well-fitting woman's shirt. Hooray. It comes in black, grey, white and two shades of blue. They are promising to add pink ones (allegedly for women), and tonsure collar shirts to the range very soon. Retailing at just under £29.35 it's fantastic value. What's not to like?
Here's the fine detail: I'm five foot five and a British size ten (USA 6). The shirt is fly front, the collar is neat without strangling you, with a 1" slip in collar. The length comes exactly to the hip bone, and has a curved hem. The fitting (on me at least) is snug but not tight round the bust and the sleeves are classic, not baggy, with no puffs. The sleeve length is perfect, a little give but not too long, and there are two buttons on each cuff so if, like me, you have a mere 6" wrist you can use the narrow one. I cannot yet comment on how it washes, but will add that later.
Any improvements? The only thing I would change on this shirt would be nicer buttons on the cuffs, where they show. (Obviously the fly front ones don't show). The existing buttons are a kind of transparent charcoal colour. Whether this is because they are made from recycled tyres or something, I couldn't say, but black ones would be nice. One other thing. I know it's a lot to ask, and this cotton really is nice and soft, but if Butler and Butler want to make women clergy really happy, they could try and source some fairly traded silk for their women's shirts. I would be first in the queue for half a dozen, even if they were double this price. (My top choice for a clergy shirt is still to buy a classic silk shirt, unpick the collar and re-stitch it with the channel open for a slip-in collar.) But meantime, whenever I buy a cotton shirt, I shall definitely be buying it from Butler and Butler, as they are absolutely the best I've tried so far.
Recent Comments